|
Full Text
1. What is Hyperhidrosis?
Hyperhidrosis is a disorder characterized by excessive sweating .
Hyperhidrosis is an unpleasant excess of sweating, in one or several parts
of the body.
Hyperhidrosis is defined as sweating that surpasses the needs of the body to
control the corporal temperature. It is a benign condition, but it can be extremely
unpleasant for most people. It is a problem that is not so rare and it occurs
in up to 1% of the population. In a city like São Paulo, with 12 million
inhabitants, there are aproximately 120.000 people with that kind of problem.
It is very likely that everyone has in their family, at their workplace or
among their friends somebody who suffers from hyperhidrosis. It is not so visible
most of the times and, feeling embarrassed, people don't like to reveal the
disease.
People who have Hyperhidrosis can present an inexplicable sweating increase
in many different situations and without any appearent cause. This increase
can be felt in the armpits (axillary hyperhidrosis) , in the hands (palmar
hyperhidrosis) , in the feet (plantar hyperhidrosis) , in the face (facial
hyperhidrosis) or in any other part of the body.
Sometimes, emotions can worsen the process of Hyperhidrosis. People can become
insecure because they think they are under emotional tension/ stress , or because
they imagine other people might think think they are under intense emotional
tension/stress. Although Hyperhidrosis can be caused and worsened because of
the emotional factor, it is wrong to say it is caused only because of psychological
reasons. In other words, for the same emotion, a person who does not suffer
from Hyperhidrosis would not present sweating excess, while the other with
Hyperhidrosis, can manifest this excess. However, the presence of Hyperhidrosis
along the years, ends up generating emotional tension that feeds the process
in a vicious cycle, where the emotional alterations intensify, turning Hyperhidrosis
into a difficult condition for a lot of people to live with.
But Hyperhidrosis can also appear without any emotion, or even without any
apparent reason. That causes patients a lot of embarrassment, giving the other
people the wrong impression of a great emotional disarray, while actually this
emotional factor does not exist in such high degree.
In some cases, people can present hyperhidrosis even in low environmental temperatures
and others, in high temperatures.
Some patients refer that they started presenting Hyperhidrosis when submitted
to larger responsibilities, usually in professional situations, or during periods
of larger emotional loads, as the adolescence, family problems, matrimonial
or economical problems. What happens is that these people already suffered
from Hyperhidrosis, but with the emotional stress, it became visible.
“The Trigger for Hyperhidrosis Syndrome”, described by Naturale Clinic’s
doctors, is the group of psychological reactions resulting from the Genetic Hyperhidrosis,
that causes anxiety and worsens the signs and symptoms.
2.Causes
Heavy jobs, exercises, the sun or hot weather; there are a lot of factors that
can cause increased sweating. The emotions can also generate sweating. And
this sweating is a normal condition that causes loss of fluid by the body
and maintains the corporal temperature stabilized.
There are 2 types of glands in the skin, the apocrines and the eccrines. The
sweat glands apocrines play a smaller role in the thermoregulation (regulation
of the corporal temperature); they are associated to the hair follicle and
they are not involved in the process of Hyperhidrosis.
The increased secretion of the glands eccrines is what causes the observed
alterations. The glands eccrines are more concentrated in the armpits, palms
and plants and have an important role in the thermoregulation. The excess of
secretion of these glands is the cause of Hyperhidrosis. There are from 2 to
5 million glands eccrines distributed in the whole body.
There are 2 types of Hyperhidrosis: the Primary and the Secondary.
Primary Hyperhidrosis does not have an specific known cause, but it is attributed
to genetic factors. People are born with the tendency to have Hyperhidrosis.
It can be manifested in the first years of life or in any subsequent phase,
which in fact is the most commom.
Secondary Hyperhidrosis, is associated to a cause. The most frequent ones are
obesity, menopause, the use of antidepressive drugs, endocrine and neurological
alterations casing the nervous system to malfunction.
Neurological and psychiatric medicines can unchain Hyperhidrosis. Morphine
and excess of the thyroid hormones also cause hyperhidrosis. Aspirin or acetominofen
overdoses can cause sweating. The lack of feminine hormones in the menopause
can lead to sweatings, and that is something that also happens to men with
testosterone deficit, although it is not very commom. The hypoglycemia (low
rate of sugar in the blood) can provoke sweating.
Sweating excess can happen when the fever, resulting from an infection, is
decreasing after the use of anti-thermal medicines. The hyperthyroidism, a
disease of the thyroid gland, is one of the causes of Secondary Hyperhidrosis.
Several infections, as tuberculosis, malaria and others, can as well cause
profuse sweating.
A sweating increase can happen in commom daily situations; that does not necessarily
mean the person developed a Hyperhidrosis condition. We can experience sweating
increase when having some substances in foods or beverages, among them, caffeine,
alcohol or even spicy foods . It is also completely normal to experience sweating
increase with exercises, hot climate and situations of emotional tension.
3. Signs and Symptoms
Most people who do not have Hyperhidrosis and even some professionals in the
health area or the patient’s family do not know how much hyperhidrosis
can disturb their sufferers. Although it is not considered a serious health
problem , only the ones who have to live with this condition can understand
the discomfort it causes. People who have hyperhidrosis refer to the sweating
excess as a great problem.
Hyperhidrosis affects men and women; it can appear in several ages.
People who suffer from Hyperhidrosis show sweating in the same conditions and
under the same incentives that the other people ; the only difference is that
it happens in larger amounts. On the other hand, they can show sweating even
in conditions where other people would not present it: in situations with low
emotional loads and in normal temperature. That ends up generating an anxiety
process that feeds Hyperhidrosis.
Formerly, the association of Hyperhidrosis to psychological problems was quite
nomal, but nowadays we understand Hyperhidrosis has a genetic causes. The patient
is born with the tendency to develop the disease. The evidence of this genetic
cause is that in the patients' families it is very common that their direct
relatives (parents, siblings, uncles, aunts or grandparents) also suffer from
the same problem. Recent publications in the USA confirm this possibility.
Another evidence of the genetic cause is that even very small children have
Hyperhidrosis.
What actually happens is that Hyperhidrosis is a great problem for their sufferers,
and it provokes psychological problems that are consequences and not the cause
of Hyperhidrosis.
These psychological alterations are easily perceptible in the patients. Therefore,
in the past, they motivated the psychological and farmacologic treatment of
this problem with not so good results . As we have already emphasized, the
psychological alterations are consequences and not the cause of Hyperhidrosis.
Many patients refer that Hyperhidrosis first appeared or worsened when they
were submitted to high professional responsibilities or to situations of emotional
distress when they were young adults or adolescents.
In adittion, many of the patients mention that just after they noticed they
started sweating, the sweating became more intense. We called that "Syndrome
of the Trigger for Hyperhidrosis."
The "Syndrome of the Trigger for Hyperhidrosis" is related the psychological
alterations provoked by Hyperhidrosis.
The patients with Hyperhidrosis, in almost it totality, can present “The
Trigger for Hyperhidrosis Syndrome”. They explain that when notice that
they are going to start sweating, they enter an anxiety process which is generated
by their own conscience. As a cosequence, they sweat in an even more intense
degree. That happens because Hyperhidrosis provokes psychological alterations
that feed the hyperhidrosis process, generating a vicious circle: Hyperhidrosis
of genetic origin provokes psychological alterations that itensify Hyperhidrosis
and, consequently, more psychological alterations, feeding the vicious circle
and generating the "The Trigger for Hyperhidrosis Syndrome"
“The Trigger for Hyperhidrosis Syndrome”, described by Naturale Clinic’s
doctors, is the group of psychological reactions resulting from the Genetic Hyperhidrosis,
that causes anxiety and worsens the signs and symptoms. That way, the psychological
alterations of Hyperhidrosis are put as consequences and not as the causes the
problem.
Therefore Hyperhidrosis is a cause of psychological problems and not itsr consequence.
Hyperhidrosis occurs mainly in the armpits, the hands and the feet, but it
can also occur in the face, mainly in the frontal area (the forehead) and the
scalp, as well as the thorax, the nape, the area under the mamma, the inguinal
area or any other area of the body.
The sufferers of Axillary Hyperhidrosis (armpits) complain about excessively
wet, stained and damaged clothes; the aspect of lack of hygiene; the impression
they give people of emotional disarray, and lack of adaptation to the necessary
clothes for their work.
The sufferers of Palmar Hyperhidrosis (hands) complain about problems to handle
papers in several types of activities, to play instruments, to type, to greet
with a handshake, in closer contacts, to drive and to practice sports. .
The sufferers of Plantar Hyperhidrosis (feet) complain about exaggerated humidity,
tendency to get mycoses and the sensation that the feet slip inside the shoes.
We could observe an increase in the number of bacteria in humid areas of the
body. Hyperhidrosis can be associated to the increase of odors of the body,
although it is not the directly responsible for this kind of problem.
4. Treatments
There are two efficient treatments for Hyperhidrosis: the Botulinum Toxin and
Sympathectomy.
Sympathectomy is a kind of surgery that has been used for a very long time,
performed with an old technique, through a cut above the clavicle, or with
a modern technique, through a small incision in the thorax and with the aid
of video equipment. It is a very efficient technique, but SYMPATHECTOMY HAS
COMPLICATIONS. These complications, although rare, are real, making the choice
of that kind of treatment a very serious decision for both the doctor and the
patient.
A new, modern and free of risk technique, the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport),
was added to the treatment of Hyperhidrosis. The injection of the Botulinum
Toxin in the hand, in the armpit or in other parts of the body eliminates the
sweating completely. The procedure is performed without the need of hospitalization.
It can be carried out in a medical clinic and the patient can return to his
normal activities on the same day. The treatment with the Botulinum Toxin is
not definitive, but other injection applications can be made every 6/12 months,
depending on the case. This procedure keeps the area being treated free of
sweating.
The advantage of the Sympathectomy is that it is definitive. The disadvantage
is that it is a surgery and complications can result from it. Some of them
may be irreversible .
The advantage of the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport) is that it does not
present any risk and it is not a surgery. Its disadvantage is that it is not
definitive. Therefore, the two techniques exist exactly because they are different.
Considering the absence of risks or complications and due to the fact that
porocedure is quite simple, we prefer using the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport)
to Sympathectomy in our Clinic. The Botulinum Toxin has undeniable advantages
to the surgical techniques. It can be applied in the hands and armpits, in
the front area of the face, in areas of the neck and in small areas of the
thorax, with risks that are practically inexistent. Naturale Clinic’s
Medical group presented the first scientific work in Brazil, the fourth in
the world, regarding the Botulinum Toxin and Hyperhidrosis.
In the past, other treatments were tried, but they did not show efficiency:
The ointments and salves use, the psychological treatments, the medicines,
the iontoforesis, the surgery to remove the glands were used with very limited
efficiency.
5. Naturale Clinic’s Treatment
Many patients can benefit from the Sympathectomy, but some few ones can not.
As the problems resulting from the surgery are unexpected and do not depend
on the doctor who performs the surgery, we prefer to treat Hyperhidrosis
with the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport) because it does not cause neither
Compensatory Hyperhidrosis nor Syndrome of Horner, and there are no surgical
complications.
If the choice is safety, the best option is the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport)
injection. If the choice is the fact of being definitive, the best option is
Sympathectomy, in spite of its important risks and possible complications.
6. The Treatment with Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX®
/ Dysport)
Although it is unpleasant, Hyperhidrosis is a benign problem. Therefore any
procedure that involves disproportionate risks to the problem should be discarded
as a treatment form. In recent years, the use of Botulinum Toxin has begun
to be dominated. This treatment has been safely used and it can be applied
for a wide variety of indications, among them, the control of Hyperhidrosis.
The Botulinum Toxin seems to be a safe and simple alternative for the control
of the excessive sweating.
In outbreaks of Botulismo B that happened in Switzerland, it was observed that
the Botulinum Toxin, besides the blocking action in the striated musculature,
it also blocked the neuro transmission of the autonomous nervous system. There
were patients with Botulism that presented sweating suppression that lasted
up to 2 years .
The first report of sweating suppression using the pharmacological Botulinum
Toxin was made in a study in 1995. At that time, a volunteer doctor injected
in himself 1 unit of Botulinum Toxin in the subcutaneous of the forearm. As
a result, the sweating of this region was decreased.
Nowadays, the Botulinum Toxin has been used to control the palmar and axillary
Hyperhidrosis and even the Hyperhidrosis of other parts of the body. The time
of action varies from 4 to 12 months, depending on the case and on area of
the injections. The effects aren’t definitive, but the repeated injections
may be used, showing great results in the immense majority of the cases.
Botulinum Toxin used for therapeutical situations is increasing, and the indications
reach wide areas of medicine. It is used in neuromuscular dystonia, in aesthetic
treatments, in oftalmologic problems, for Frey’ s Syndrome, muscular
spasms, and an indication that promises to be very positive, the tensional
migraine. Frequently, patients who are submitted to the Botulinum Toxin treatment
for aesthetic control of the forehead wrinkles, refer to the improvement of
chronic tensional migraine. It is not hard to find patients who regularly use
the Botulinum Toxin to control wrinkles requesting the re-injections because
of the improvement they obtained in chronic tensional migraine they previously
suffered from.
Although several vascular surgeons who are part of our group are used to the
technique of the Sympathectomy, we prefer using the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX®
/ Dysport). We do not use Sympathectomy because of the risks involved in it.
They are rare, but real and may cause definitive complications as the syndrome
of Horner, that is the fall of the eyelid, an unsightly complication, that
cannot be corrected. This decision is mainly because of the risk of Compensatory
Hyperhidrosis (profuse sweating in another part of the body as a consequence
of Sympathectomy)
BOTOX® is already a widely known product, although there are others like Dysport
and Myoblock. It is a substance that has been used by the medicine for a long
time. In great doses, it is a powerful poison; in small doses, it is a wonderful
medicine.
The Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport) is used for the treatment of muscular
contractions, wrinkles, migraine, spasms, spastic paralyses, hyperactivity
of sphincters, and many others fields of the medicine. Recently, new uses for
this substance have been discovered, including the control of Hyperhidrosis.
When applied in the skin, the Botulinum Toxin turns the nerve of the sweat
gland off. It is as if it turned off the light switch. The nerve is quite normal
and so is the sweating gland, but there is no passage for the nervous impulse
that provokes the sweating. As Hyperhidrosis is just a sweating abundance,
the Botulinum Toxin is able to abolish Hyperhidrosis temporarily.
As the nerve is normal and so is the sweating gland , after a period of time
that depends on the place where the Botulinum Toxin was injected in the body,
there is a reconnection of the nerve and the gland. As a result, the nervous
impulse reaches the gland and the sweating appears again. But the Botulinum
Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport) can be injected repeatedly, causing the Hyperhidrosis
to decrease again.
If the necessity of re-injecting the Botulinum Toxin seems to be inconvenient,
it is in fact a warranty that if any complication happens, they will be reversible.
These problems are rare and practically inexistent. With Sympathectomy, things
are different; if the procedure results in complications, they aren’t
reversible.
7. Hyperhidrosis - Treatment with the Botulinum
Toxin - Efficiency length of the blocking action
In Naturale Clinic’s researches, we observed that the suppression of
Hyperhidrosis does not last the same for all patients. In the case of the armpit,
the chemical blocking action is efficient for an average of 7,33 months, varying
from 4 to 12 months. With the evolution of the technique, the efficiency of
this substance is going to be increased.
There is also another very important effect of the Botulinum Toxin called Psychological
Residual " Positive Effect ". What happens is that, once applied,
the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport) will cause the suppression of the sweating
for the length of time mentioned above. However, we have noticed that although
the chemical effect disappears after this period of time, the patients take
longer to return for new injections. Even taking longer to re-inject the substance,
92% refer an improvement in their quality of life. Another important fact is
that 61% of the patients, refer that Hyperhidrosis reappeared in smaller amounts
than the initial phase.
Almost all the patients present “The Trigger for Hyperhidrosis Syndrome”,
a condition we have already described. That means that when they notice they
are going to start sweating, they sweat even more. That is a result of an anxiety
process generated by the patient’s conscience.
Recent reports associate Hyperhidrosis to genetic basis. However, psychological
alterations are easily perceptible in the patients who suffer from hyperhidrosis.
In old times, these psychological alterations motivated the use of medicines
and psychological treatment, with no uniform results.
We believed that the psychological alterations are consequences and not the
cause of Hyperhidrosis. Hyperhidrosis is observed even in children of very
young age who haven’t been submitted to the psychological processes of
life. This is a strong argument against the psychological causes of the problem.
However, many patient refer that Hyperhidrosis appear or is worsened when they
are submitted to pressures of life , like professional responsibility when
they are young adults or in the adolescence. We repeat, because it is important,
that almost all the patients present what we called “The Trigger for
Hyperhidrosis Syndrome”; they explain that when they notice they are
going to start sweating, they sweat even more. That causes an anxiety process
which results in an even more intense sweating condition.
That happens because Hyperhidrosis causes psychological alterations that generate
a vicious circle: Hyperhidrosis, of genetic origin, provokes psychological
alterations that provoke more Hyperhidrosis and, consequently, more psychological
alterations. That feeds the vicious circle and causes " The Trigger for
Hyperhidrosis Syndrome" .
The transitory chemical suppression of the sweating with the Botulinum Toxin
makes the patients feel more confident. The patients understand they control
the sweating, re-injecting the toxin when necessary. The patients did not have
this capacity before. In other words, the vicious circle is broken; the trigger
is disarmed with the positive psychological action of the toxin. This positive
psychological action of the toxin is responsible for smaller sweat volumes
observed in many patients after its chemical effects are finished.
The psychological alterations of Hyperhidrosis are consequences and not the
cause of the problem. The suppression of the sweating with Botulinum Toxin
has an immediate chemical effect and a positive psychological late effect,
what results in better quality of life for the patients. “The Trigger
for Hyperhidrosis Syndrome” is the group of psychological reactions resulting
from the Genetic Hyperhidrosis, that causes anxiety and worsens the signs and
symptoms.
As the Botulinum Toxin injection (BOTOX® / Dysport) is a very simple procedure,
it can be performed at the clinic. In our opinion, it is the best alternative
to control most of the cases of Hyperhidrosis. .
8. How the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport)
is applied
How to perform the treatment of Hyperhidrosis with the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX®
/ Dysport)
8.1 the Appointment
We suggested an appointment before the injection of Botulinum Toxin for the
correct evaluation of the case and planning of the treatment. Besides, it
is the time for explanations to the patient and an important time to answer
eventual doubts. If the patient comes from another place/city, the appointment
can be scheduled for the same day of the procedure, and the previous explanations
can be given by telephone or E-mail.
8.2 the Procedure
It is performed at the clinic for cases of axillary, plantar or facial Hyperhidrosis.
In cases of plantar Hyperhidrosis, the treatment is performed at the day
hospital. The treatment is performed under local anesthesia . After the local
anesthesia, the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport) is applied in the skin
of the affected area. The whole procedure takes an average of 15 minutes
for each armpit and 25 minutes for each hand.
8.3 preparation before the treatment
Just a good hygiene of the area to be treated with medicinal soap is necessary
.
8.4 after the treatment of axillary Hyperhidrosis
It is not necessary any special care. The patient can return to his professional
activities immediately. Exercises can be practiced on the following day.
8.5 after the treatment of Hyperhidrosis of the hands
The patient can return to his normal activities immediately after the end of
the local anesthesia effect. We just advise the patient to avoid the use
of the hands in activities that expose them to the dust, grease, etc, for
one day. Exercises can be practiced on the following day. Exercises with
weights can be practiced after two days.
9.History
It was a German poet, who was also a doctor and scientist, that explained the
disease called botulism. Dr. Justinus Kerner of Wurttemberg, published the
first studies about the disease from 1817 to 1822. Dr. Kerner, a representative
of the romantic German poetic movement, had his poems turned into music by
Schumann. But in his first studies of the botulism, Dr. Kerner already imagined
that the toxin that caused such a serious disease, could be used to treat
diseases like muscular spasms. That great poet, great doctor, excellent scientist,
and amazing human being, always stood out in all of the areas he was involved.
But the medical poet could not glimpse that this toxin would one day be used
to treat people's appearance and to make them happier.
In 1978, the toxin was applied in humans as treatment by Scott, and surprisingly,
it was so safe that it would be used in many other medical indications, besides
the aesthetics field. Jean Carrhuters worked with Scott applying the toxin
for strabismus treatment. A strabismus patient treated by Carrhuters told him
her wrinkles got a lot better after the toxin was applied. Along with her husband,
Jean Carrhuters started to use the toxin for cosmetic proposes; it was the
beginning of a revolution that we have observed in the treatment of the wrinkles
and of the aging of the facial skin .
In a Botulism B epidemia in Switzerland, it was observed that the Botulinum
Toxin, besides the blocking action in the striated musculature, it also blocked
the neuro transmission of the autonomous nervous system. There were patients
with Botulism that presented sweating suppression that lasted up to 2 years
.
The first report of sweating suppression using the pharmacological Botulinum
Toxin was made in a study in 1995. At that time, a volunteer doctor injected
in himself 1 unit of Botulinum Toxin in the subcutaneous of the forearm. As
a result, the sweating of this region was decreased.
Then, in Europe, there were studies to block the sweating in volunteers without
Hyperhidrosis, and finally, in patients with axillary Hyperhidrosis. Therefore,
later in the USA, the toxin was applied in Hyperhidrosis of the hands.
Naturale Clinic’s head, Miguel Francischelli Neto MD PhD, presented the
first scientific work in Brazil about the use of the Botulinum Toxin to control
the Hyperhidrosis. This scientific work was the fourth in the world. Many other
works , BY Prof. Francischelli, followed this one.
The use of toxins are part of the history of the medicine. It was the same
with the penicillin produced by a mushroom, and with the captopril, a drug
that is widely used for hypertension derived from the “jararaca” snake
poison. Many other toxins resulting from natural substances have been used
as well. The doses used for the treatment of the wrinkles are around 30 times
inferior to the ones that would cause larger complications or diseases. This
makes all the procedure very safe. The doctor, poet and scientist Kerner, would
be satisfied if he saw such dangerous toxin being tamed and used for the happiness
and the improvement of the people's quality of life
10. Video Endoscopic Sympathectomy
The videoendoscopic Sympathectomy is performed under general anesthesia. A
stem is introduced through a small cut in the thorax. With the aid of the
video, the surgeon identifies the sympathetic nerve. Through a cautery, the
responsible nerves for Hyperhidrosis are destroyed. The technique is efficient,
with excellent results. But it presents complications, among them, the most
frequent one is the Compensatory Hyperhidrosis (a sweating increase in other
parts of the body), that it is a very unpleasant situation.
The surgical treatment of Hyperhidrosis, the Sympathectomy, involves the removal
of a specific part of the main sympathetic nerve. It is well knon that the
sympathetic nerves are part of a separate and parallel nervous system. The
anatomical position and the function is separate from the somatic nerve system(volunteer),
which are the nerves that control the sensations and the movements. The "chain" of
sympathetic nerves is formed by a group of nerves located close to the ribs
in the thorax. They are very close to the spine. The nervous branches, that
leave the ganglions, reach the gland and stimulate the sweating. There is a
ganglion in each vertebral level of the spine and all these ganglions are attached
one to another longitudinally forming the "sympathetic chain". The
branches of the sympathetic nerve come off each one of these ganglions and
they will act on the blood vessels and sweating glands in the body. The surgical
therapy for Hyperhidrosis requests the removal and destruction of this specific
ganglion that cause the sweating of the hands and armpit. There is a variety
of manners of working with the sympathetic ganglions: removing, cauterizing,
or cutting the branches. All of these techniques are capable to block Hyperhidrosis.
In the classic technique to treat Palmar Hyperhidrosis (hands), the ganglion
of T2 is moved away or destroyed. Many surgeons will also remove the third
ganglion to maximize the chance to stop the sweating of the hands completely.
To treat the armpit, the second and third ganglion is moved away or destroyed.
Just the same, some surgeons will also destroy the fourth ganglion to maximize
the result. To reduce the possibility of Compensatory Hyperhidrosis, the ganglions
are being more selectively chosen. But this does not guarantee that compensatory
Hyperhidrosis won't happen and it increases the chances of reoccurance of Hyperhidrosis.
In the past, an incision of larger size was used in the thorax or in the lateral
of the neck. That demanded cuts with scars to expose the sympathetic chain.
However, recent progresses in technology produced less invasive methods, such
as the videoendoscopic Sympathectomy. This requests general anesthesia for
the patient. Once asleep, two or three small holes (5-10 mm) are performed
in the thorax. Through these holes, an endoscope with a video camera sends
images to the doctor. With this technique, the sympathetic chain can be identified.
Through the incisions, instruments are intrduced to allow the surgeon to remove
and destroy the specific ganglions, depending on the patient's symptoms. To
perform this operation, the patient's lung has to be collapsed to allow appropriate
space for the surgeon to maneuver. After the conclusion of the operation, the
lung is refilled and the incisions are closed. Occasionally, a small tube is
maintained inside the thorax to allow evacuation of air, however, that is removed
some hours after the surgery. After a side is completed, the surgeon repeats
the procedure on the opposite side
Usually, the patients leave the hospital in a period of 24 hours following
the surgery. There is some post-operative pain, which requires medication for
some days.
11. Complications of the Sympathectomy
11.1 Compensatory Hyperhidrosis
When Videoendoscopic Sympathectomy is performed, with the destruction of the
sympathetic chain, the Hyperhidrosis in the superior members is extinguished,
whether it is in the hand or in the armpit. However, the capacity to sweat
does not disappear only in the armpit and in the hands, but also in the whole
superior member and part of the thorax and neck. As the sweating is a form
of regulating the temperature of the body, an increase of sweating in other
parts of the body can be felt. This process is normal after a surgery and
it is called Compensatory Hyperhidrosis. For most of the patients, Compensatory
Hyperhidrosis is light and it can disappear after some time. This condition
is acceptable and the patient has a better situation than the initial problem
of axillary and palmar Hyperhidrosis that motivated the surgery. However,
in a smaller percentage of cases, around 5 to 10%, Compensatory Hyperhidrosis
is unpleasant and in rare cases worse than the previous situation. Some patients
complain about sweating in the abdominal region , on the back, in the inguinal
area, part of the face, or in the feet. The Compensatory Hyperhidrosis does
not depend on the surgeon's expertise, because it is not only a complication,
but a side effect of the treatment that can happen in different ways for
each patient.
Some patients feel so disturbed by the Compensatory Hyperhidrosis that they
would like to revert the surgery. This is not possible nowadays, although some
attempts have been made in other countries, but with poor results.
In some cases, injections of Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport) can improve
Compensatory Hyperhidrosis.
When we use injections of Botulinum Toxin for the treatment of Hyperhidrosis,
there is no risk of Compensatory Hyperhidrosis since the treated area is not
the whole superior member as in Sympathectomy. The treatment with Botulinum
Toxin is performed in a smaller area, corresponding to the Armpit or the Hand.
This is the main reason why we prefer the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport)
to Sympathectomy to treat Hyperhidrosis.
11.2 Gustatory Hyperhidrosis
Another potential side effect is the gustatory sweating. Patient that develop
this type of problem increase the sweating when they are eating. This happens
in approximately 5-10% of the patients, but it is rarely severe.
11.3 Syndrome of Horner
Another fortunately very rare problem that can be a side effect of a Sympathectomy
is the syndrome of Horner. That means the the drop of the eyelid. These complication
although rare, is irreversible.
There is a ganglion called “sttellate” , from where nervous fibers
that are responsible for maintaining the eyelid open come off. During a Videoendoscopic
Sympathectomy for Hyperhidrosis, due to alterations of the anatomy or due to
the heat of the cauterization of the vases close to the sttelate ganglion,
this ganglion can be damaged during the surgery. As a result, an inadvertent
lesion of this ganglion can happen.
Such situation does not depend on the surgeon's expertise; it could happen
even when the surgeon takes the maximum of care. Although it is a very rare
situation, it can happen in numbers that vary from 1 to 5% of the surgeries
performed. Although rare, it is the most feared complication of the surgery
of videoendoscopic Sympathectomy.
11.4 General Risks
Other complications as bleeding (hemotorax) and perforation of the lung (pneumotorax)
can happen, but they are rare and treatable. There may be cases of complications
resulting from the anesthesia, although in their majority, they are controllable.
The infection is rare, but there is a risk. Because an endoscope and instruments
are passed between the ribs, it is possible to damage an artery, a vein or
a nerve that run under each rib. This could potentially lead to a bleeding
or inflammation of the nerve with chronic irritation or pain. Although most
of these operations are performed in young adults, older patients are exposed
to larger probability of complications when they undergo this procedure.
These patients are subject to the risks of heart problems (heart attack,
abnormal rhythm), pneumonia, clot, and infections and urinary infections.
The incidence of any of these potential complications is very low (1% or
less) but such problems can appear with any surgery form, and the patients
should be aware of all of the risks involved. Lung adherences can hinder
or impede the treatment, increasing risks.
11.5 Justifying our position
Many patients are benefitted by the Sympathectomy, but some few ones are not.
As there are unexpected situations that do not depend on the doctor who performs
the procedure, we prefer treating Hyperhidrosis with the Botulinum Toxin
(BOTOX® / Dysport). This is our choice because the procedure does not cause
Compensatory Hyperhidrosis, Syndrome of Horner, or surgical complications.
If the choice is safety, the best option is the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® /
Dysport). If the choice is the fact of being definitive, the best option
is Sympathectomy . 12. Sympathectomy X Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport)
Most of the patients who are submitted to the Sympathectomy can benefit from
it, but others can not. The number of patients who develop Compensatory Hyperhidrosis
and who are unhappy with the results can reach 10%. Besides, this is a condition
that is frequently not reversible.
Many patients are benefitted by the Sympathectomy, but some few ones are not.
As they are unexpected situations that do not depend on the doctor who performs
the procedure, we prefer treating Hyperhidrosis with the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX®
/ Dysport). This is our choice because the procedure does not cause Compensatory
Hyperhidrosis, Syndrome of Horner, or surgical complications. If the choice
is for safety, the best option is the Botulinum Toxin (BOTOX® / Dysport). If
the choice is the fact of being definitive, the best option is Sympathectomy
. "Although we recognize the risks of the videoendoscopic Sympathectomy
are rare, we state that no doctor can say they do not exist. That’s the
reason why we have chosen the treatment with injections of Botulinum Toxin
(BOTOX® / Dysport) to control Hyperhidrosis. We have not suggested or performed
Sympathectomy as a treatment for Hyperhidrosis. In the future, if the method
proves to be safer and more previsible in relation to its complications, we
can review our position "
This is the opinion of Naturale Clinic’s medical team, which has already
been clearly declared in publications in medical magazines and presented in
Congresses as well. However, we remind that other points of view are accepted
by the medical and scientific community, including the practice of the Sympathectomy,
that is performed by many institutions in Brazil and in other countries. This
is a subject that is still in development and in debate.
last actualization:
|